Showing posts with label Private Colleges. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Private Colleges. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 24, 2012

You Won't Fix Colleges With Standardized Tests

David Brooks shares some observations about college:
Colleges are supposed to produce learning. But, in their landmark study, “Academically Adrift,” Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa found that, on average, students experienced a pathetic seven percentile point gain in skills during their first two years in college and a marginal gain in the two years after that....

This research followed the Wabash Study, which found that student motivation actually declines over the first year in college. Meanwhile, according to surveys of employers, only a quarter of college graduates have the writing and thinking skills necessary to do their jobs.
But perhaps the problem is not with colleges, per se, and is more the consequence of a culture shift: the notion that everybody can and should attend college. The more lazy, unmotivated, disinterested and/or untalented students you place a college class, the more you change the classroom experience.

As much as Brooks laments the good old days, which apparently means 1961,1 when "students spent an average of 24 hours a week studying", I'm skeptical both of self-reports of hours spent studying (particularly those cherry-picked from a half-century ago) and also of the implication that, prior to the entry of the unwashed masses courtesy of student loans and the G.I. Bill, colleges historically did a better job educating students than they do at present - at least if the student wants to learn. The "Gentleman's C" for children of the wealthy and well-connected is part of that same history.

Brooks also appears to hold the conceit that during the post-war boom employers were deeply concerned about how much their new hires had learned in college. The college graduates I know from that era describe how the subject matter of their degree didn't much matter to employers. Their bachelor's degrees were akin to a union card, something that qualified them for jobs that required bachelor's degrees. Something similar happened in the late 1980's and early 1990's, as computer technology expanded and people were welcomed into computer and IT jobs with little regard for their undergraduate major, or even if they had completed a college degree. Similarly, there was a period in the 2000's during which consulting firms could not hire enough MBA's and started to draw in graduates from law schools and other programs. If the pool of candidates with the preferred degree is too small, employers will expand the applicant pool. When the pool of degreed candidates is sufficient, the "union card" effect returns.

Meanwhile, contrary to Brooks' suggestion, students are more aware than ever of the market value of their degrees. For many years, a significant population of incoming students has been asking, "What sort of job can I get with this degree," not "How much will I learn along the way." Some of my relatives who easily obtained jobs after completing college in the 1960's and 1970's are testaments to the fact that, in a booming job market, weak critical thinking skills and majoring in partying are not significant impediments to getting a job.

Does Brooks believe that MBA graduates are in slight demand? As graduate programs go it's an easy degree, two years, no capstone or thesis. Business students are among those who study the least while in college. How does Brooks reconcile that with his notion that employers want colleges to produce hard-working students who study a lot?

In his analysis, Brooks makes a classic error: he believes that education can make you smarter. Education can help you learn to reason, can provide a structure for more efficient thinking, and can help you maximize your potential, but it cannot make you smarter.

Here's another dirty little secret: When Brooks talks about colleges that are interested in assessing how much and how well their students are learning, he speaks of "schools like Bowling Green and Portland State". Not schools like Harvard or Yale. Why? If you can be extremely selective in terms of who you admit, although you may not show a significantly higher improvement of your students' critical thinking skills over the course of their degree programs, they start and end at a higher point than their peers at less exclusive institutions. But more than that, we're back to the union card issue. Schools like Harvard and Yale have done a great job branding themselves and, by implication, their graduates. In a nationwide job market, even when there's a glut of job seeking graduates from schools like Bowling Green and Portland State, the numbers of Harvard and Yale graduates does not increase - and between their small number and the exclusivity of their brand, they have an advantage in the job market even if they're not as intellectually qualified as their state school peers. If you recruit at Harvard you're also apt to get somebody who "fits" with an organization that serves the needs of society's well-heeled. Will a graduate from Bowling Green have similar social experiences coming in the door? Why gamble, right? Let's also not forget how many jobs are obtained through connections as opposed to through job fairs and advertisement - roughly 60% - and Ivy league schools insert you into fantastic networks.

Brooks' notion that you can measure college learning in a manner that is "real and transparent to outsiders" is, to put it mildly, absurd. If employers want to know whether their applicants can perform certain tasks, it's easy enough for the employer to impose a testing requirement as part of the application process. Further, as with any test, a testing process focuses on matters that are often subjective or arbitrary, and a one-time test tells you little that is useful. How would Brooks imagine that tests could be made objective and transparent, but at the same time be objective, fair, minimize cheating, relevant to any given student's curriculum, revised annually, and updated2 regularly (in many cases it would have to be annually) so as to ensure continued relevance to employers?

Brooks has the notion that a college could come up with its own assessment method and "broadcast the results to prospective parents, saying, 'We may not be prestigious or as expensive as X, but here students actually learn.'" The problems with that? Multiple. First, once the assessment method is implemented, assuming it works, it will be years before employers will see any difference in the graduating class. If a school has a weak reputation it would involve a tremendous leap of faith by a student to enroll based upon the promise that a new "assessment method" will result in their being a hot commodity in the job market by the time they graduate. And even after the new improved graduates start graduating, it will be years before employers trust that the change is real, not just hype, and even then you won't be Harvard, Yale, or anything close to it. You may have better graduates, but you won't have the brand, the network, the endowment, the exclusivity....

The best way to improve the quality of your graduating class is to improve the quality of your incoming freshmen. But colleges are tripping over each other trying to bring in students in order to maintain tuition revenue, creating the opposite effect - students who really shouldn't be attending college are able to get admitted and are often able to graduate. Those students are not going to be helped by "assessment methods" at the college level, any more than they were made college-ready through standardized testing during their K-12 years. It is a glut of college graduates, not hours spent studying or attempts to measure improvement in critical thinking, is the most profound cause of the commoditization of the college diploma. And to the extent that employers no longer trust that colleges screen out undesirable employees, that's an inevitable consequence of removing any meaningful barriers to college enrollment.
-------------------
1. Recall that Brooks appears to believe that U.S. culture peaked in 1963.

2. Here I speak of revision in terms of producing a different set of questions from year to year, as otherwise the answers get out, and of updates in terms of making sure that the subject matter of the test remains current and relevant, a significant and difficult task.

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

Tying Student Loans to Graduates' Employment Records

Sam Petula suggests that if you explicitly tie student loans to how college graduates do in the employment market, you can put pressure on colleges to scale back or even eliminate certain academic programs:
Last week’s announcement of new rules to bear down on career colleges like the University of Phoenix, which offer degrees in programs like Health Administration and Criminal Justice Administration, weren’t designed to force those questions. These programs come under a different section in the Higher Education Act, excluding them from regulations for how much money their graduates make. But the new rules—the gainful employment rules, as they’re called—could push federal regulators to start peering under the hood of more traditional colleges majors, according to reporting by Inside Higher Ed.
I'm reminded of recent reports about the college degrees that pay the least, with the psychology major being held out as a prime example of a popular but low-paying major. I majored in psychology (although principally because I wanted to graduate - I could have graduated a semester later with a major in chemistry, general science or political science), so I can attest both that you won't find job ads seeking candidates with bachelor's degrees in psychology and that it doesn't matter, because a bachelor's degree in psychology is not designed to be a terminal degree. If you want to be a psychologist, you continue toward a Ph.D., and if you don't you get a graduate degree in whatever field you intend to pursue. The knowledge you gain from the study of psychology can be helpful in other fields, but does not qualify you to be a mental health professional.

To the extent that students entering college believe that "Chinese literature", "religious studies" or "women's studies" are terminal degrees, colleges should be educating them to the contrary. If a traditional college is being anywhere near as misleading toward people majoring in those fields as the for-profits often are in relation to the job opportunities and incomes they suggest can be achieved through their programs, those colleges deserve a similar consequence.

There's a degree of difficulty in comparing a two year certificate program from a private university, that does little to nothing for a graduate's job prospects, with a four year degree that is meant to be followed by a graduate education. The better comparison is to community colleges which typically offer similar degree or certification programs at a significantly lower cost, and without the false promises or exploitation of the federal student loans. It would have made no sense to tell me that I would not qualify for student loans based upon my major... well, first because I went to a then-inexpensive state college, worked a ridiculous number of hours, lived on a shoestring, and graduated from my undergraduate program with no student loan debt, but ignoring that for a moment... because I could have simply and very plausibly declared a different major in order to qualify for loans, and also because my plan was to continue to graduate school such that my nominal major didn't matter.

To the extent that the government's hand appears too heavy, it's not because the government is cracking down on private colleges to the extent truly necessary to correct abuses - most of the teeth have been pulled from the final regulations. I would rather the concept of colleges acquiring insurance for the student loan moneys that they distribute, such that they could do what they wanted but in the event that their graduates didn't find jobs would find the insurance coverage for their students' loans to become unavailable (or, if you prefer, increasingly expensive and, with no corrections, ultimately unaffordable). The "lack of value" in a particular non-terminal four-year degree would be mitigated by the fact that the majority of recipients would continue through graduate school, and thus should not play a significant role in a college's insurance premiums.

Monday, May 09, 2011

"But College Graduates Earn More"

One of the arguments made by proponents of near-universal college attendance is that college graduates earn more over their lifetimes than do people who did not attend college. That's true based upon historical earning figures and averages, but even during peak years of income for college graduates you will find examples of college graduates who, thanks to their choice of degree or academic performance, have limited opportunity for income, as well as plenty of examples of people who did not attend or who dropped out of college and ended up making a great deal of money. A similar analysis could also be made of specific college programs, and would no doubt demonstrate that graduates within certain fields of study (e.g., engineering, architecture, math, computer science) on average earn significantly more money than those from other fields (e.g., social work, communications, political science, philosophy, art).

It's also important to recall that the opportunistic proponents of "college for all" are pushing for-profit colleges, paid for by student loan, that often produce both high debt and a certification that has little to no "real world" value. With an abundance of college graduates to choose from, a college degree is also becoming a de facto requirement for a broad array of jobs that were formerly open to high school graduates. The issue isn't whether a degree is necessary to perform the job - it's that the requirement of a college degree is a quick and easy way to shorten the stack of applicants, and suggests also that college graduates are no more expensive to hire than their peers who lack degrees.

If you want to argue that "College is a voyage of discovery, and everybody who wants the opportunity for that voyage should be able to take it," fair enough - but you should be honest that the subject has shifted away from maximizing income, and also that there is a price to be paid - tuition costs, student loan debts, opportunity costs, etc. - in taking four or more years to pursue that voyage of self-discovery. Not everybody can afford the luxury of a college education. If you push universal college on this basis, you also need to consider how it affects other students - having significant numbers of unqualified or disinterested students in their classes can detract significantly from the college experience. Like it or not, college subsidies are going to continue to trend downward.

If you want to make the purely economic argument then you should be looking at more than "college vs. no college". You should break your argument down so that people making the choice based upon your promise of heightened future income will have the information necessary to select a course of studies that is likely to lead to higher income. If that seems to mercenary, then you're really making a "voyage of discovery" argument. If not, then college should be presented among a full range of career options so that the prospective student can make an informed choice.

Friday, January 07, 2011

Colleges Are Not Equal

In the Washington Post's latest unsurprising effort to keep taxpayer money rolling into Kaplan (okay... maybe they truly believe it's for the good of the country, not just the company), they offer another defense of the high student loan default rate at private... no, let's use the word "career" colleges.

Although isn't "private" far more accurate, given that they're not including community colleges within that new conceit? And for many of the "careers" at issue, there's no degree requirement for entry to the field? And community college classes to get a certification or to build an equivalent body of knowledge come at a significantly lower price? And many graduates don't in fact find the degree earned helpful when starting a career? But I digress.
Minority students attend career colleges in much higher proportions than do other students, and these are the only schools targeted by the proposal.
I've addressed this before:
[I]f privatizing education is supposed to be a miracle cure for K-12 education, why is "our students are harder to teach" supposed to be an acceptable excuse for the performance of for-profit institutions of higher education? Their students want to go to school and, either with cash or student loan money, are paying for the privilege - you can assume some degree of motivation. Why is it only appropriate to blame schools and teachers for poor outcomes, and insist that the composition of the student body should be irrelevant, when they're part of the public sector?
Also, as previously suggested, the alternative to full-time enrollment at a "career college" that doesn't provide a career - hence the high default rate - is community college. Why is part-time enrollment at a significantly lower cost per credit, or even full-time enrollment if an equivalent community college program is available, a bad thing?
Many career colleges receive their accreditations through the same agencies as the nation's top private and nonprofit universities, which would be spared from the effects of the rule (though 93 percent of historically black colleges would fail the rule's repayment rate test if it were applied to them).
You only need a rudimentary knowledge of the difference between four year colleges and private "career colleges" to understand why you can't compare apples to oranges. And frankly, if a four year college is performing so badly that it can be fairly compared to a "career college" diploma mill, the solution is to apply the new rule to that college as well, not to keep throwing away public money to subsidize private "career colleges" that offer useless degrees.
Career colleges are different only in that they are the schools of choice for many at-risk students, including minorities, parents and full-time workers who believe these schools offer them the best shot at a good job in a field they will enjoy.
If we assume that true, shouldn't the solution be to better educate them such that they recognize that many "career colleges" are a waste of time and money? Believe it or not, if you end up with $40K or more in debt for a "career college" degree that turns out to be worthless in the job market, and you also incur two years of opportunity loss association with your time off of the job market while attending the program or working part-time, you're not better off for the experience. And if you can't make enough money to pay back your government-backed student loans, that's horrible for you - you are stuck with debts that will hound you for decades - and for the taxpayers who pick up the tab. When students default, the only people making out like bandits are the proprietors of the colleges. Talk about moral hazard....

I personally believe we would be better off taking a look at student loans across the board, and putting more responsibility on all colleges to ensure that the loans they convince their students to take are ultimately paid back. Such as by insuring student loans rather than guaranteeing them. That would create a nice, equal playing field for "career colleges" - but I can already hear the squawking.

Friday, December 03, 2010

The Hardships of For-Profit Education

The President of the Association of Private Sector Colleges and Universities complains about a recent New York Times article on the sorry performance of private educational institutions,
The Education Trust report you cite unfairly criticizes the career education sector and devalues the education and commitment of its 3.2 million students. Comparing private-sector colleges and universities to other types of institutions does not consider the larger percentages of high-risk students we serve.
I recently irked a company that operates for-profit charter schools by suggesting,
Stop and think about that for a minute. If you're wealthy, your kids don't go to the University of Phoenix, and your kids certainly won't be attending the "charter school" equivalent of the University of Phoenix. It's quaint to pretend that if only corporations are permitted to pull profits out of the per-student fees allocated to charters we'll suddenly have thousands of schools across the country offering rich curricula and pedagogical choices. But if you look at the for-profit college industry you can see what you actually get - bottom feeders. No kidding, the advocates of that system are encouraging people to ignore test scores.
But here's the thing: if privatizing education is supposed to be a miracle cure for K-12 education, why is "our students are harder to teach" supposed to be an acceptable excuse for the performance of for-profit institutions of higher education? Their students want to go to school and, either with cash or student loan money, are paying for the privilege - you can assume some degree of motivation. Why is it only appropriate to blame schools and teachers for poor outcomes, and insist that the composition of the student body should be irrelevant, when they're part of the public sector?

Also, let's be honest - we're largely talking about diploma mills that churn out degrees that few believe hold any real value, or encourage students to pursue certification for jobs that traditionally have not required any formal education beyond high school, where the same certification can be achieved for a lot less money through a community college, or both. And where the certification obtained may not even be valued by employers.

The author's best attempt at a defense of the Association's members is,
At least the Education Trust concedes that graduation rates at two-year career colleges are much higher than those of community colleges.
Except that "concession" is footnoted,
Caution should be used when comparing graduation rates at for-profits and public community colleges because of differences in the length of academic programs. See Christopher M. Mullins, “Just How Similar? Community Colleges and the For-Profit Sector,” American Association of Community Colleges, AACC Policy Brief 2010-04PBL, November 2010.
Notably,
About 89% of students at 2-year for-profit, 86% at less-than-2-year for-profit, and 73% at 4-year for-profit institutions enroll full time, compared with about 40% of students at community colleges. This fundamental difference in enrollment intensity, in addition to the many short-term programs offered at for-profit institutions, substantially increases for-profits’ completion rates.

When transfer rates are included in graduation rate analyses, community colleges and 2-year for-profit institutions have completion rates of 40% and 61%, respectively.
If somebody is going to drop out of college, doing so as a part-time community college student would be far less of an economic detriment than doing so as a full-time private college student; I thought that was one of the reasons for community college - to let people supplement their skills without worrying about whether or not they might get a degree, and to let others see if they have the interest or aptitude to pursue a college degree without necessarily quitting their day job or making a large financial commitment.

If for-profits become big players in the charter school world, displacing public schools in the inner cities, how much doubt do you have that once they're established we'll hear the same complaint offered in the defense of private colleges: "Our performance issues aren't our fault - our students are hard to teach."

Sunday, August 22, 2010

For-Profit Colleges and Student Loans

As people reading this blog probably know, the Washington Post owns Kaplan, Inc., which returns profits well in excess of those earned by the newspaper. In editorializing for the continuation of subsidized loans to private colleges that have astronomical default rates, the Post discloses its ownership of Kaplan but neglects to inform readers that Kaplan is the jewel in its corporate crown.

I'm reminded of a comment by Adam Serwer that pretty much sums up how a lot of those colleges work - and why their default rate is so high.
Universities like this make money by promising easy routes to well-paying and doable careers that in the past really never required a formal degree: those in the culinary arts, massage therapy and support staff for medical and legal professionals. The growth in these programs just take advantage of students who don't have access to traditional non-profit college degrees.

Moreover, there's no evidence it helps them. It's hard to imagine that someone with a degree in retail management will never get higher than retail management, which for the most part is not a lucrative career.
The student graduates with significant student loan debt to compete for entry level, low-wage jobs. Consider, for example, the lack of return for most students who enroll in culinary arts schools, or the anecdote recounted in this forum post about a private college instructor's candid disclosure. If it takes you two years to complete the degree program, odds are you would have been better off spending those two years working in the field and earning experience.

I'm not saying you can't learn valuable skills in those programs, but those skills won't necessarily be valued by employers. You want to start your own catering business? Great. But even then you may be better off working in the field and selectively taking some classes to round out your food knowledge before starting your own enterprise.